Activist U.S. Supreme Court Makes It Official, Were Now The Corporate States Of America

Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Stephen Breyer clashed over the role the Supreme Court has in overturning its own precedents Wednesday during arguments in a major Mississippi abortion case.

The case, Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, has the potential to overturn Roe v. Wade.

"History tells a somewhat different story, I think, than is sometimes assumed," Kavanaugh said about stare decisis -- the principle that the court should stick to its past rulings.

"If you think about some of the most important cases in this court's history... there's a string of them where the cases overruled precedent," he said.

Kavanaugh continued: "Brown v. Board outlawed separate but equal. Baker versus Carr, which set the stage for one person, one vote. West Coast Hotel, which recognized the state's authority to regulate business. Miranda versus Arizona, which required police to give warnings... about the right to remain silent... Lawrence v. Texas said that the state may not prohibit same sex conduct. Mapp v. Ohio, which held that the exclusionary rule applies to state criminal prosecution."

"In each of those cases... and I could go on. And those are some of the most consequential and important in the court's history, the court overruled precedent," Kavanaugh said.

A few minutes later Breyer slammed Kavanaugh for making allegedly false equivalencies between Roe and the other cases he cited.

"They do not include the list that Justice Kavanaugh had here... There are complex criteria that she's talking about that link to the position in the rule of law of this court," Breyer said. "All I would say is tou have to read them before beginning to say whether they are overruling or not overruling in the sense meant there calling for special concern."

Breyer was referring to the opinion of former Justice Sandra Day O'Conner in Planned Parenthood v. Casey analyzing when to overturn major precedents.

U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar agreed.

"This is actually another key distinction from the cases that Justice Kavanaugh was referring to," she said. "The decision to overrule nevertheless, perhaps based on the... conclusion that the justices thought the case was wrongly decided in the first instance, would run counter to the ability of stare decisis to function as a cornerstone of the rule of law."

Source : https://www.foxnews.com/live-news/supreme-court-mississippi-abortion-roe

398
Supreme Court hears Mississippi abortion case that could overturn Roe v. Wade: LIVE UPDATES

Source:Fox News

Supreme Court hears Mississippi abortion case that could overturn Roe v. Wade: LIVE UPDATES

Americans love a powerful Supreme Court, but its not good for us

Source:Yahoo News

Americans love a powerful Supreme Court, but its not good for us

Conservative Supreme Court justices consider upholding Mississippi abortion law

Source:New York Post

Conservative Supreme Court justices consider upholding Mississippi abortion law

‘It is a terrifying time’: Legal right to abortion in US faces direct challenge at Supreme Court

Source:Yahoo

‘It is a terrifying time’: Legal right to abortion in US faces direct challenge at Supreme Court

U.S. Supreme Court conservatives appear willing to gut abortion rights

Source:Cyprus Mail

U.S. Supreme Court conservatives appear willing to gut abortion rights

Supreme Court hears Mississippi abortion case with major implications for Roe v. Wade

Source:CBC.ca

Supreme Court hears Mississippi abortion case with major implications for Roe v. Wade

Supreme Court: Top US judges signal support for abortion limits

Source:Yahoo News

Supreme Court: Top US judges signal support for abortion limits

Supreme Court abortion case: Sotomayor grills Mississippi on ‘stench’ of politics in landmark hearing

Source:MSN

Supreme Court abortion case: Sotomayor grills Mississippi on ‘stench’ of politics in landmark hearing